Review Article
Split ViewerApplication Development of Baihui (GV20) Moxibustion in Ancient China: a Data Analysis Study Based on Ancient Books
1Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China
2Yueyang Hospital of Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China
3Shanghai Research Institute of Acupuncture and Meridian, Shanghai University of TCM, Shanghai, China
This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
J Acupunct Meridian Stud 2024; 17(4): 123-132
Published August 31, 2024 https://doi.org/10.51507/j.jams.2024.17.4.123
Copyright © Medical Association of Pharmacopuncture Institute.
Abstract
Observations: The Chinese Medical Classic (5th edition) was used as the search source to screen and organize articles related to Baihui moxibustion to establish a database. We created indexing norms according to study characteristics and indexed books, dynasties, literary styles, disease key words, matching acupoints, combinations, moxibustion amounts, and moxa cone sizes. SPSS version 24.0 software was used to calculate the index results. A total of 320 articles that met the requirements were finally included and were attributed to 99 ancient books, spanning from the Western Han Dynasty to the Qing Dynasty. A total of 45 keywords were used for disease evidence: the most frequent occurrences were internal medicine (primary category), limb meridians (secondary category), and head diseases (specific patterns).
Conclusions and Relevance: Baihui moxibustion has been updated and developed in the literature over the ages, and the method of Baihui moxibustion is diverse. The main treatment rule of Baihui moxibustion considers the whole body and close treatment of partial diseases. Baihui moxibustion also has the rule of following meridian indications, with treatment based on syndrome differentiation and compatible application. Baihui moxibustion alone has a relatively strong effect of raising yang and lifting the sunken, which can treat the sinking of qi and deficiency.
Keywords
INTRODUCTION
The acupoint Baihui (GV20) first appeared in the book
Compared to acupuncture, Baihui moxibustion slowly penetrates through the heat effect, leaning towards the method of warming and tonifying, while acupuncture directly stimulates acupoints, rapidly invigorating meridian Qi and blood, leaning towards the method of purging. Baihui moxibustion was first documented in the
METHODS
1. Literature search
The fifth edition of
-
Table 1 . Table of synonyms
Original search term Synonym Baihui Dianshang (巔上, top), Ding Zhongyang (頂中央, top center), Lingshang (嶺上, ridge), Niwan (泥丸, mud pills), Sanyang (三陽, tri-yang) , Wuhui (五會, five convergence), Sanyangwuhui (三陽五會, tri-yang and five convergence), Tianman (天滿), Weihui(維會) Moxibustion Ai (艾, Moxa), Zhuang (壯, stick), Zhi (炙, scorching), Yun (熨, ironing), Lao (烙, branding), Denghuo (燈火, lamp fire)
2. Inclusion criteria
Studies meeting the following criteria were included: (1) articles focusing on the use of Baihui moxibustion for disease treatment; (2) articles discussing the compound application of Baihui moxibustion; (3) medical cases related to Baihui moxibustion for disease treatment; (4) narrative articles outlining the indications of Baihui moxibustion; (5) articles in the pithy formula documenting the indications of Baihui moxibustion; (6) articles presenting opposing viewpoints on Baihui moxibustion.
3. Exclusion criteria
Studies meeting the following criteria were excluded: (1) articles pertaining to positioning; (2) articles discussing Baihui alias; (3) articles focusing on the circulation of relevant meridians; (4) articles lacking clear descriptions of disease syndromes; (5) articles with unclear operational methods; (6) articles published after the Republic of China era.
The latter one of any two duplicate articles was excluded if: (1) the statements were consistent; (2) the meaning conveyed was the same; (3) the statements were different, but the diagnosis, patterns, acupuncture, and frequency were completely consistent; (4) the original article provided a marked source that could be traced; (5) the viewpoints expressed were similar to earlier articles without introducing new content.
4. Data indexing and specification
A database was established with index book serial numbers, dynasties, genre types, disease keywords, acupoints, compatible treatment methods, moxibustion quantities, and moxa sizes in Excel tables. Statistical analyses were conducted on the established database. Align the Jin Dynasty to the Song Dynasty based on actual years, and for cases where the dynasty is unknown, adhere to the research perspective of the most recent version. Genres were classed into medical theory, medical prescriptions, medical cases, and medical formulae based article style.
The diseases and patterns recorded in different ancient books differed and required standardization according to statistical requirements. Ancient Chinese medicine indexing differs from the modern literature, posing challenges for summarizing articles using contemporary terms [13]. At present, there is no clear indexing specification for ancient Chinese medicine books. To address this, the authors designed a keyword-based, four-level, disease-pattern indexing scheme:
1) Determination of the disease name
The original article was used to identify the diagnosis if a clear diagnosis was provided. In cases where the original article lacked a clear diagnosis but described patterns, the diagnosis was based on the primary pattern in the article. If a sentence included multiple diagnoses, all were listed without using the disease name itself as statistical content.
2) Indexing the primary disease category
Diseases were categorized under internal medicine, surgery, gynecology, pediatrics, and ophthalmology. Diseases such as vertigo and headache were classified as internal medicine.
3) Indexing the secondary disease category
Diseases were further categorized under internal medicine into subcategories like exogenous disease, hepatobiliary, cardiocerebral conditions, and spleen and stomach, lung, kidney, and limb meridians. Surgery was divided into limb meridians, trauma, anorectal and vulva, skin diseases, and mammary glands. Gynecology was divided into menstruation, vaginal discharge, obstetrics, anorectal, and vulva. Pediatric cases were re-indexed under pediatrics, if applicable. Five sense organs’ illness includes ophthalmology, ear disease, rhinopathy, mouth and teeth disease, and laryngeal disease. Oral and dental disease includes only independent oral and dental related diseases.
4) Identifying specific patterns
Patterns were summarized based on common features in disease descriptions, such as wind, blood, pain, convulsions, spasms, collapse, phlegm, cold, heat, and cold and heat. Diseases were classified based on common characteristics, and standardized according to disease names such as diarrhea, jaundice, sores and carbuncles, convulsions, silence, epilepsy, etc. For complex cases, categories were created like “head disease”, which encompassed various head-related conditions, such as head trauma, various encephalopathies, mental illnesses, ear, nose, and throat diseases, etc. Descriptors like “urgent pattern” were used for acute cases with words such as “Bao” (暴) and “Ji” (急). Words with “Jiu” (久) and “Qianyan” (遷延) were designated as “long time pattern”. The relevant disease patterns in the
5) Indexing various primary/secondary categories
Diseases treatable by different categories or with major and major-combined patterns were indexed accordingly. For instance, cases with wind or convulsion patterns alongside limb issues were indexed as “limb meridian patterns”, while cases with mental health concerns were categorized under “heart and brain”. Index examples are shown in Table 2.
-
Table 2 . Index example
Book Text Keyword Shen Ying Jing Sick for a long time and have a runny nose: Baihui moxibustion. ENT, nose disease, internal medicine, lung disease, long pattern, head disease Gu Jin Yi Tong Da Quan: Tuo Gang Hou Baihui, on the top of head, has three sticks of moxibustion to treat pediatric prolapse. Pediatric, surgery, proctology and vulvar disease, collapse pattern Tai Ping Sheng Hui Fang: Ti Huang Zheng Hou Patients who have yellow body, yellow face, sore and stuffy feet and knees, not warm on the body, restless in the heart, slightly aerated in the abdomen, better or worse appetite, prefer covering, but want to sleep in a cold place, should have moxibustion on Baihui, back center and one to two inches, three inches, four inches, and five inches below the heart. Internal medicine, hepatobiliary disease, jaundice, limb meridians. cold and heat pattern, head disease, heart and brain disease, pain pattern
5. Statistical analyses
This study was conducted using SPSS version 24.0 software (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). Frequencies and proportions were calculated as descriptive statistics. Prism software (version 8.0.2; USA) was used to plot the results.
RESULTS
A total of 7193 articles with “Baihui” and its synonyms were retrieved, along with 580 articles retrieved through searches for moxibustion and its synonyms. Overall, 554 articles were obtained, excluding duplicates and articles unrelated to Baihui. As the
-
Figure 1.Flow diagram of the search and screening of the texts included in this study.
1. The ancient book information of Baihui moxibustion method
A total of 320 texts from 99 ancient books were examined, with the earliest two being the
Among all the ancient books, the greatest number of texts on Baihui moxibustion was found in
-
Table 3 . The top 10 ancient books in terms of texts
Ancient book name Dynasty Rank Text Proportion (%) Zheng jiu ji cheng Qing 1 28 8.8 Pu ji fang Ming 2 27 8.4 Sheng ji zong lu Northern Song 3 21 6.6 Zhen jiu zi sheng ji Southern Song 4 17 5.3 Tai ping sheng hui fang Northern Song 5 16 5.0 Gu jin yi tong da quan Ming 6 10 3.1 Bei ji qian ji nyao fang Tang 7 9 2.8 Jiu fa mi chuan Qing 8 8 2.5 Yi xue gang mu Ming 9 7 2.2 Zhen jiu da cheng Ming 10 6 1.9 Qian jin yi fang Tang 10 6 1.9
-
Figure 2.Frequency of texts and books by dynasty.
2. Literary style of Baihui moxibustion
The literary style of Baihui moxibustion recorded in ancient books was divided into four categories. The largest category consisted of medical prescriptions, with 202 texts (63.1%), followed by 92 medical expounds (28.8%), 19 medical cases (5.9%), and 7 pithy formulas (2.2%). Pithy formulas were found exclusively in texts from the Ming and Qing Dynasties. The Western Han Dynasty and Eastern Jin Dynasty produced the two medical expounds (Fig. 3).
-
Figure 3.Proportion of Baihui moxibustion’s literary style. (A) Total proportion, (B) proportion by dynasty.
3. Methods of Baihui moxibustion
Among the methods of Baihui moxibustion, multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion was the most common, with 180 texts, representing 56.3% of the total. The second most common method was single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion, with 79 texts, accounting for 24.7% of the total. Combinations of acupuncture and moxibustion were found in 15 texts (4.7%), while combinations of acupuncture, moxibustion, and medicine were present in 46 texts (14.4%). The Western Han and Eastern Jin Dynasties mostly used multi-acupoint moxibustion, which decreased to 48.1% in the Qing Dynasty. Single-acupoint moxibustion and the combination of multiple therapies showed increasing trends over time (Fig. 4).
-
Figure 4.Proportion of Baihui moxibustion’s operation method. (A) Total proportion, (B) proportion by dynasty.
4. Disease characteristics of Baihui moxibustion
A total of 45 keywords were identified for the disease. Among the primary categories, internal medicine had the highest frequency of mention (263 times). The top five secondary categories were limb meridians (156), heart and brain disease (130), hepatology (35), spleen and stomach disease (32), and anorectal and vulval disease (28). The top five specific patterns were head disease (105), wind (76), collapse (46), and diarrhea and epilepsy (34; Table 4 and Fig. 5).
-
Table 4 . Indications of Baihui Moxibustion
Category Keyword (frequency) Primary category Internal medicine (263), pediatric (71), surgery (46), ENT (29), gynaecology (11) Secondary category Limb meridians (156), heart and brain (130), hepatology (35), spleen and stomach (32), anorectal and vulva (28), nose disease (11), exogenous disease (9), lung disease (8), trauma (8), eye disease (6), obstetrics (5), dental disease (5), kidney disease (5), skin disease (4), ear disease (3), throat disease (3), leucorrhea disease (2), postpartum disease (2) Specific
patternHead disease (105), wind pattern (76), collapse pattern (46), diarrhea (34), epilepsy (34), jaundice (33), acute pattern (32), infantile convulsions (26), syncope (25), prostration (24), pain pattern (21), cold pattern (19), long time pattern (18), silence (16), cold and hot pattern (15), Shaoyin disease (13), hot pattern (9), convulsions (8), blood pattern (6), phlegm wet pattern (4), sores and carbuncles (2), jueyin disease (1)
-
Figure 5.Indications of Baihui Moxibustion.
5. Disease characteristics of single-acupoint and multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion
There were 79 texts on single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion, encompassing 39 disease keywords. Among the primary categories, internal medicine had the highest frequency (60 occurrences). The top five secondary categories were heart and brain disease (28), limb meridians (23), and anorectal and vulval disease (14). The top three specific patterns were collapse (22), diarrhea (22), and head disease (19). For multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion, there were 180 texts involving 41 disease keywords. Internal medicine remained the primary category with the highest frequency (153 occurrences). The top three secondary categories were limb meridians (96), heart and brain disease (73), and hepatology (31). The top three specific patterns were head disease (59), wind (49), and jaundice (29; Table 5).
-
Table 5 . Indications of single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion and multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion
Category Single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion (frequency) Multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion (frequency) Primary category Internal medicine (60), pediatric (24), surgery (19), ENT (4), gynaecology (4) Internal medicine (153), pediatric (37), surgery (19), ENT (19), gynaecology (4) Secondary category Heart and brain (28), limb meridians (23), anorectal and vulva (14), spleen and stomach (14) Limb meridians (96), heart and brain (73), hepatology (31), spleen and stomach (9), exogenous disease (8), anorectal and vulva (8), lung disease (5), nose disease (5) Specific
patternCollapse pattern (22), diarrhea (22), head disease (19), wind pattern (14), Shaoyin disease (12), long time pattern (9), infantile convulsions (9), prostration (8), epilepsy (8), acute pattern (7) Head disease (59), wind pattern (49), jaundice (29), epilepsy (21), acute pattern (19), silence (15), infantile convulsions (13), prostration (12), collapse pattern (12), cold and hot pattern (12), pain pattern (10), syncope (10), cold pattern (8), diarrhea (6), hot pattern (6), convulsions (5) *Omit keywords with frequency less than 5.
6. Specific methods of Baihui moxibustion
Besides direct moxibustion, ancient books also recorded indirect Baihui moxibustion: two mentions each of moxibustion on garlic, moxibustion on ginger, and plaster; and one mention each of moxibustion on locust bark, and lampwick moxibustion.
DISCUSSION
Statistical analyses revealed that Baihui moxibustion was documented across various dynasties. Apart from the Western Han and Eastern Jin Dynasties, where only medical treatises mention Baihui moxibustion, the genre predominantly consists of medical prescriptions in all other dynasties. Since the Yuan Dynasty, the prevalence of medical expounds has gradually increased. Baihui moxibustion involving multiple acupoints has received more attention than single-acupoint moxibustion. During the Northern Song Dynasty, single-acupoint moxibustion was the least frequently mentioned, with only two occurrences. The prevalence of single-acupoint moxibustion gradually increased from the Yuan Dynasty to the Ming Dynasty and further to the Qing Dynasty.
The therapeutic indications of Baihui moxibustion encompass various physiologic systems. The Baihui acupoint serves as the convergence point of Yang qi and the central hub of all meridians [14]. It is efficacious in treating both upper and lower body ailments and can be used for tonification, purgation, invigoration, and constriction. Mugwort, the primary herb used in moxibustion, exhibits properties of divergence, warmth, and bitterness, possessing pure yang attributes. Its application can rescue patients from collapse and facilitate unobstructed flow of the body’s meridians. Internal medicine constitutes the predominant domain within the primary categories of Baihui moxibustion, underscoring the overall leadership role of the Baihui acupoint. Within the secondary categories, the main indications revolve around limb meridian disorders and cerebrovascular ailments, suggesting that Baihui moxibustion can invigorate mental faculties and enhance overall vitality through meridian stimulation. Specific patterns of application predominantly target cranial disorders and wind-related syndromes, indicating the efficacy of Baihui moxibustion in addressing ailments proximal to the Baihui acupoint.
Single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion is effective in treating internal medicine ailments, particularly those affecting the heart and brain, diarrhea, and collapse disorders. Such moxibustion functions by enhancing yang energy and uplifting sinking qi. For example, in the
The
The
Baihui moxibustion encompasses effects such as yang-warming, alleviation of collapse, awakening the mind, and calming agitation, making such moxibustion a versatile treatment for various cognitive disturbances. As stated in
Some doctors have proposed unique insights on the clinical application of Baihui moxibustion.
The primary method of Baihui moxibustion was direct moxibustion, although alternative approaches such as using garlic, ginger, or locust bark were also documented. Historic texts mention combining Baihui moxibustion with external medicine to address conditions like wind-induced head rotation and nasal congestion. For instance,
In researching Baihui acupoint-related practices, Taoist techniques like “storing mud pills” were considered. The
CONCLUSIONS
With the advancement of acupuncture and moxibustion, the clinical use of Baihui moxibustion has evolved across various dynasties, showcasing its versatile methodologies. Indications for Baihui moxibustion are reflected in commanding the whole body and the close treatment effect of local diseases, as well as following the main treatment of meridians and the application of syndrome differentiation and treatment. Single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion potently tonifies and elevates sinking qi, making it effective for conditions characterized by qi deficiency and descent. This research only covered the texts related to Baihui moxibustion in ancient books included in the
FUNDING
This research was funded by the Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 16th Batch of Student Innovation Activity Program Project (No. 202310268131, SHUTCM2023096).
AUTHORS’ CONTRIBUTIONS
Ma YY and Qu CC performed the texts’ search and screen. Ma YY and Chen LM performed the writing. Ji J proposed guidance and modifications. All the authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
- Huang F. Zhen Jiu Jia Yi Jing. Xian: Xi'an Jiaotong University Press, 2018, p. 89. Chinese.
- Zhang J. Lei Jing Tu Yi. Beijing: People's Medical Publishing House, 1965, p. 309. Chinese.
- Chen W, Zhang Y, Zhang C, Jia H. [Analysis of ancient clinical application of baihui point based on data mining technology]. Jianxi J Tradit Chin Med 2014;45:27-31. Chinese.
- Yan C. [Overview of Baihui acupoint therapy in ancient books]. J Anhui Uni Chin Med 2013;31:57-60. Chinese.
- Anonymous. Suwen. Taiyuan: Shanxi Science and Technology Press, 2019, p. 121.
- Shanghai Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion Editorial Board. Baihui moxibustion in ancient literatures. Shanghai J Acupunct Moxibustion 2003;11:24.
- Wu Q. Study on Modern Clinical Application of Baihui Moxibustion Therapy. Jinan: Shandong University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2017.
- Qiu P, Deng T, Wang Y. Chinese Medical Classic. 5th ed. Changsha: Human Electronic Audiovisual Press, 2013.
- Shen X. Meridian and Acupoint. 10th ed. Beijing: China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 2016, p. 171.
- Wang D. Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion Acupoint Guide (Part 1). Qingdao: Qingdao Press, 2004, p. 232.
- Gao X. Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion Dictionary. Nanjing: Jiangsu Science and Technology Press, 2010, p. 242.
- Huang L. A study of the origin and development of moxibustion. J Clin Acupunct Moxib 1995;9:11-2.
- Shang W, Zhang H, Duan Q, Hou Y, Jiang D, Meng F. [A study on the practice of online deep citation of ancient Chinese medical books]. J Changchun Uni Chin Med 2013;29:555-7. Chinese.
- Yang J. Compendium of Acupuncture and Moxibustion. Tianjin: Tianjin Science and Technology Press, 2017, p. 86.
- Dou G. Huang Di Ming Tang Jiu Jing Jiu Gao Mang Shu Xue Fa Zi Wu Liu Zhu Zhen Jing Zhen Jing Zhi Nan. Beijing: People's medical publishing, 1983, p. 63.
- Zhu Z, Zhang Q, Deng J, Zhenheng Z, Qiwendeng Z. Dan Xi Zhi Fa Xin Yao. Jinan: Shandong Science Technology Press, 1985, p. 49. Chinese.
- Xu C. Complete Collection of Ancient and Modern Medical Statistics (Part 2). Hefei: Anhui Science and Technology Press, 1995, p. 305.
- Yuan H, Yang B. [Overview of clinical applications of the Baihui acupoint]. J Prac Tradit Chin Med 2021;37:2138-41. Chinese.
- Zhang Z. Treatise on Cold Damage Diseases. Nanning: Guangxi Science and Technology Press, 2015, p. 82.
- Guo Y. Shang Han Bu Wang Lun. Beijing: People's Health Press, 1994, p. 182. Chinese.
- Zhang L. Shang Han Cuan Lun. Beijing: China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 2015, p. 85. Chinese.
- Ke Q. Shang Han Lun Zhu. Beijing: People's Military Medical Electronic Press, 2011, p. 79. Chinese.
- Qian H. Shang Han Su Yuan Ji. Beijing: China Traditional China Medicine Publisher, 2015, p. 335. Chinese.
- Chen M, Zhou J, Feng T, Duan X, Xiao L. [Brief discussion on the clauses without specific acupuncture point in Shanghan Lun]. China J Tradit Chin Med Pharm 2018;33:4031-3. Chinese.
- Gong Y. Shou Shi Bao Yuan. Taiyuan: Shanxi Science and Technology Press, 2006, p. 660. Chinese.
- Li S. Yi Xue Yan Yue. Beijing: China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 1997, p. 233. Chinese.
- Wang Z. Zhen jiu zi sheng jing. Shaghai: Shanghai Scientific and Technical Publishers, 1959, p. 158. Chinese.
- Yang S, Fan D, Su S, Wang C, Lin Y, Liang M. Effects of pressing moxibustion at Baihui (GV 20) and Guanyuan (CV 4) on cognitive impairment and serum levels of Aβ1-42, tau, P-tau in patients with mild to moderate Alzheimer's disease. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 2024;44:255-60.
- Xu CW, Wang TT, Chen LP, Liu XL, Yang Z, Chen DR, et al. Observation on the short-term efficacy of inverse moxibustion at the Baihui point and Dazhui point in preventing post-stroke depression. Explore (NY) 2023;19:607-10.
- Mai W, Bu XZ, Miao FR, Rui JL, Huang LL, Zhao XJ, et al. [Moxibustion at Baihui combined with acupuncture for cervical vertigo: a meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis]. Zhen Ci Yan Jiu 2023;48:95-101. Chinese.
- Ju YL, Chi X, Liu JX. Forty cases of insomnia treated by suspended moxibustion at Baihui (GV 20). J Tradit Chin Med 2009;29:95-6. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0254-6272(09)60040-6.
- Liu K. Song Feng Shuo Yi. Beijing: People's Health Press, 1987, p. 107. Chinese.
- Zhao J. Sheng Ji Zong Lu. Beijing: China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 2018, p. 2524. Chinese.
- Zhu Z. Puji Fang Book 2 Body Shape. Beijing: People's Health Press, 1959, p. 78.
- Danbo K. Yi Xin Fang. Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press, 1998, p. 1124. Chinese.
- Wang LF, Meng YL. [Study on literatures of health preservation and practitioners in
Taiping Yulan :Fangshu ]. Zhonghua Yi Shi Za Zhi 2019;49:224-8. Chinese. - Jing X. A study on the origin of the brain marrow theory in traditional Chinese medicine. China J Tradit Chin Med Pharm 1997;5:21-24+64.
Related articles in JAMS
Article
Review Article
J Acupunct Meridian Stud 2024; 17(4): 123-132
Published online August 31, 2024 https://doi.org/10.51507/j.jams.2024.17.4.123
Copyright © Medical Association of Pharmacopuncture Institute.
Application Development of Baihui (GV20) Moxibustion in Ancient China: a Data Analysis Study Based on Ancient Books
Ma Yueying1,2 , Chen Liming1,2,* , Qu Changcheng1 , Ji Jun2,3
1Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China
2Yueyang Hospital of Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China
3Shanghai Research Institute of Acupuncture and Meridian, Shanghai University of TCM, Shanghai, China
Correspondence to:Chen Liming
Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China
E-mail chenliming@shutcm.edu.cn
This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Abstract
Importance: We compile and analyze ancient literature related to Baihui (GV20) moxibustion and summarize the development of its ancient clinical application.
Observations: The Chinese Medical Classic (5th edition) was used as the search source to screen and organize articles related to Baihui moxibustion to establish a database. We created indexing norms according to study characteristics and indexed books, dynasties, literary styles, disease key words, matching acupoints, combinations, moxibustion amounts, and moxa cone sizes. SPSS version 24.0 software was used to calculate the index results. A total of 320 articles that met the requirements were finally included and were attributed to 99 ancient books, spanning from the Western Han Dynasty to the Qing Dynasty. A total of 45 keywords were used for disease evidence: the most frequent occurrences were internal medicine (primary category), limb meridians (secondary category), and head diseases (specific patterns).
Conclusions and Relevance: Baihui moxibustion has been updated and developed in the literature over the ages, and the method of Baihui moxibustion is diverse. The main treatment rule of Baihui moxibustion considers the whole body and close treatment of partial diseases. Baihui moxibustion also has the rule of following meridian indications, with treatment based on syndrome differentiation and compatible application. Baihui moxibustion alone has a relatively strong effect of raising yang and lifting the sunken, which can treat the sinking of qi and deficiency.
Keywords: Baihui acupoints, Literature research, Moxibustion
INTRODUCTION
The acupoint Baihui (GV20) first appeared in the book
Compared to acupuncture, Baihui moxibustion slowly penetrates through the heat effect, leaning towards the method of warming and tonifying, while acupuncture directly stimulates acupoints, rapidly invigorating meridian Qi and blood, leaning towards the method of purging. Baihui moxibustion was first documented in the
METHODS
1. Literature search
The fifth edition of
-
Table 1
Table of synonyms.
Original search term Synonym Baihui Dianshang (巔上, top), Ding Zhongyang (頂中央, top center), Lingshang (嶺上, ridge), Niwan (泥丸, mud pills), Sanyang (三陽, tri-yang) , Wuhui (五會, five convergence), Sanyangwuhui (三陽五會, tri-yang and five convergence), Tianman (天滿), Weihui(維會) Moxibustion Ai (艾, Moxa), Zhuang (壯, stick), Zhi (炙, scorching), Yun (熨, ironing), Lao (烙, branding), Denghuo (燈火, lamp fire)
2. Inclusion criteria
Studies meeting the following criteria were included: (1) articles focusing on the use of Baihui moxibustion for disease treatment; (2) articles discussing the compound application of Baihui moxibustion; (3) medical cases related to Baihui moxibustion for disease treatment; (4) narrative articles outlining the indications of Baihui moxibustion; (5) articles in the pithy formula documenting the indications of Baihui moxibustion; (6) articles presenting opposing viewpoints on Baihui moxibustion.
3. Exclusion criteria
Studies meeting the following criteria were excluded: (1) articles pertaining to positioning; (2) articles discussing Baihui alias; (3) articles focusing on the circulation of relevant meridians; (4) articles lacking clear descriptions of disease syndromes; (5) articles with unclear operational methods; (6) articles published after the Republic of China era.
The latter one of any two duplicate articles was excluded if: (1) the statements were consistent; (2) the meaning conveyed was the same; (3) the statements were different, but the diagnosis, patterns, acupuncture, and frequency were completely consistent; (4) the original article provided a marked source that could be traced; (5) the viewpoints expressed were similar to earlier articles without introducing new content.
4. Data indexing and specification
A database was established with index book serial numbers, dynasties, genre types, disease keywords, acupoints, compatible treatment methods, moxibustion quantities, and moxa sizes in Excel tables. Statistical analyses were conducted on the established database. Align the Jin Dynasty to the Song Dynasty based on actual years, and for cases where the dynasty is unknown, adhere to the research perspective of the most recent version. Genres were classed into medical theory, medical prescriptions, medical cases, and medical formulae based article style.
The diseases and patterns recorded in different ancient books differed and required standardization according to statistical requirements. Ancient Chinese medicine indexing differs from the modern literature, posing challenges for summarizing articles using contemporary terms [13]. At present, there is no clear indexing specification for ancient Chinese medicine books. To address this, the authors designed a keyword-based, four-level, disease-pattern indexing scheme:
1) Determination of the disease name
The original article was used to identify the diagnosis if a clear diagnosis was provided. In cases where the original article lacked a clear diagnosis but described patterns, the diagnosis was based on the primary pattern in the article. If a sentence included multiple diagnoses, all were listed without using the disease name itself as statistical content.
2) Indexing the primary disease category
Diseases were categorized under internal medicine, surgery, gynecology, pediatrics, and ophthalmology. Diseases such as vertigo and headache were classified as internal medicine.
3) Indexing the secondary disease category
Diseases were further categorized under internal medicine into subcategories like exogenous disease, hepatobiliary, cardiocerebral conditions, and spleen and stomach, lung, kidney, and limb meridians. Surgery was divided into limb meridians, trauma, anorectal and vulva, skin diseases, and mammary glands. Gynecology was divided into menstruation, vaginal discharge, obstetrics, anorectal, and vulva. Pediatric cases were re-indexed under pediatrics, if applicable. Five sense organs’ illness includes ophthalmology, ear disease, rhinopathy, mouth and teeth disease, and laryngeal disease. Oral and dental disease includes only independent oral and dental related diseases.
4) Identifying specific patterns
Patterns were summarized based on common features in disease descriptions, such as wind, blood, pain, convulsions, spasms, collapse, phlegm, cold, heat, and cold and heat. Diseases were classified based on common characteristics, and standardized according to disease names such as diarrhea, jaundice, sores and carbuncles, convulsions, silence, epilepsy, etc. For complex cases, categories were created like “head disease”, which encompassed various head-related conditions, such as head trauma, various encephalopathies, mental illnesses, ear, nose, and throat diseases, etc. Descriptors like “urgent pattern” were used for acute cases with words such as “Bao” (暴) and “Ji” (急). Words with “Jiu” (久) and “Qianyan” (遷延) were designated as “long time pattern”. The relevant disease patterns in the
5) Indexing various primary/secondary categories
Diseases treatable by different categories or with major and major-combined patterns were indexed accordingly. For instance, cases with wind or convulsion patterns alongside limb issues were indexed as “limb meridian patterns”, while cases with mental health concerns were categorized under “heart and brain”. Index examples are shown in Table 2.
-
Table 2
Index example.
Book Text Keyword Shen Ying Jing Sick for a long time and have a runny nose: Baihui moxibustion. ENT, nose disease, internal medicine, lung disease, long pattern, head disease Gu Jin Yi Tong Da Quan: Tuo Gang Hou Baihui, on the top of head, has three sticks of moxibustion to treat pediatric prolapse. Pediatric, surgery, proctology and vulvar disease, collapse pattern Tai Ping Sheng Hui Fang: Ti Huang Zheng Hou Patients who have yellow body, yellow face, sore and stuffy feet and knees, not warm on the body, restless in the heart, slightly aerated in the abdomen, better or worse appetite, prefer covering, but want to sleep in a cold place, should have moxibustion on Baihui, back center and one to two inches, three inches, four inches, and five inches below the heart. Internal medicine, hepatobiliary disease, jaundice, limb meridians. cold and heat pattern, head disease, heart and brain disease, pain pattern
5. Statistical analyses
This study was conducted using SPSS version 24.0 software (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). Frequencies and proportions were calculated as descriptive statistics. Prism software (version 8.0.2; USA) was used to plot the results.
RESULTS
A total of 7193 articles with “Baihui” and its synonyms were retrieved, along with 580 articles retrieved through searches for moxibustion and its synonyms. Overall, 554 articles were obtained, excluding duplicates and articles unrelated to Baihui. As the
-
Figure 1. Flow diagram of the search and screening of the texts included in this study.
1. The ancient book information of Baihui moxibustion method
A total of 320 texts from 99 ancient books were examined, with the earliest two being the
Among all the ancient books, the greatest number of texts on Baihui moxibustion was found in
-
Table 3
The top 10 ancient books in terms of texts.
Ancient book name Dynasty Rank Text Proportion (%) Zheng jiu ji cheng Qing 1 28 8.8 Pu ji fang Ming 2 27 8.4 Sheng ji zong lu Northern Song 3 21 6.6 Zhen jiu zi sheng ji Southern Song 4 17 5.3 Tai ping sheng hui fang Northern Song 5 16 5.0 Gu jin yi tong da quan Ming 6 10 3.1 Bei ji qian ji nyao fang Tang 7 9 2.8 Jiu fa mi chuan Qing 8 8 2.5 Yi xue gang mu Ming 9 7 2.2 Zhen jiu da cheng Ming 10 6 1.9 Qian jin yi fang Tang 10 6 1.9
-
Figure 2. Frequency of texts and books by dynasty.
2. Literary style of Baihui moxibustion
The literary style of Baihui moxibustion recorded in ancient books was divided into four categories. The largest category consisted of medical prescriptions, with 202 texts (63.1%), followed by 92 medical expounds (28.8%), 19 medical cases (5.9%), and 7 pithy formulas (2.2%). Pithy formulas were found exclusively in texts from the Ming and Qing Dynasties. The Western Han Dynasty and Eastern Jin Dynasty produced the two medical expounds (Fig. 3).
-
Figure 3. Proportion of Baihui moxibustion’s literary style. (A) Total proportion, (B) proportion by dynasty.
3. Methods of Baihui moxibustion
Among the methods of Baihui moxibustion, multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion was the most common, with 180 texts, representing 56.3% of the total. The second most common method was single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion, with 79 texts, accounting for 24.7% of the total. Combinations of acupuncture and moxibustion were found in 15 texts (4.7%), while combinations of acupuncture, moxibustion, and medicine were present in 46 texts (14.4%). The Western Han and Eastern Jin Dynasties mostly used multi-acupoint moxibustion, which decreased to 48.1% in the Qing Dynasty. Single-acupoint moxibustion and the combination of multiple therapies showed increasing trends over time (Fig. 4).
-
Figure 4. Proportion of Baihui moxibustion’s operation method. (A) Total proportion, (B) proportion by dynasty.
4. Disease characteristics of Baihui moxibustion
A total of 45 keywords were identified for the disease. Among the primary categories, internal medicine had the highest frequency of mention (263 times). The top five secondary categories were limb meridians (156), heart and brain disease (130), hepatology (35), spleen and stomach disease (32), and anorectal and vulval disease (28). The top five specific patterns were head disease (105), wind (76), collapse (46), and diarrhea and epilepsy (34; Table 4 and Fig. 5).
-
Table 4
Indications of Baihui Moxibustion.
Category Keyword (frequency) Primary category Internal medicine (263), pediatric (71), surgery (46), ENT (29), gynaecology (11) Secondary category Limb meridians (156), heart and brain (130), hepatology (35), spleen and stomach (32), anorectal and vulva (28), nose disease (11), exogenous disease (9), lung disease (8), trauma (8), eye disease (6), obstetrics (5), dental disease (5), kidney disease (5), skin disease (4), ear disease (3), throat disease (3), leucorrhea disease (2), postpartum disease (2) Specific
patternHead disease (105), wind pattern (76), collapse pattern (46), diarrhea (34), epilepsy (34), jaundice (33), acute pattern (32), infantile convulsions (26), syncope (25), prostration (24), pain pattern (21), cold pattern (19), long time pattern (18), silence (16), cold and hot pattern (15), Shaoyin disease (13), hot pattern (9), convulsions (8), blood pattern (6), phlegm wet pattern (4), sores and carbuncles (2), jueyin disease (1)
-
Figure 5. Indications of Baihui Moxibustion.
5. Disease characteristics of single-acupoint and multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion
There were 79 texts on single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion, encompassing 39 disease keywords. Among the primary categories, internal medicine had the highest frequency (60 occurrences). The top five secondary categories were heart and brain disease (28), limb meridians (23), and anorectal and vulval disease (14). The top three specific patterns were collapse (22), diarrhea (22), and head disease (19). For multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion, there were 180 texts involving 41 disease keywords. Internal medicine remained the primary category with the highest frequency (153 occurrences). The top three secondary categories were limb meridians (96), heart and brain disease (73), and hepatology (31). The top three specific patterns were head disease (59), wind (49), and jaundice (29; Table 5).
-
*Omit keywords with frequency less than 5..
&md=tbl&idx=5' data-target="#file-modal"">Table 5Indications of single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion and multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion.
Category Single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion (frequency) Multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion (frequency) Primary category Internal medicine (60), pediatric (24), surgery (19), ENT (4), gynaecology (4) Internal medicine (153), pediatric (37), surgery (19), ENT (19), gynaecology (4) Secondary category Heart and brain (28), limb meridians (23), anorectal and vulva (14), spleen and stomach (14) Limb meridians (96), heart and brain (73), hepatology (31), spleen and stomach (9), exogenous disease (8), anorectal and vulva (8), lung disease (5), nose disease (5) Specific
patternCollapse pattern (22), diarrhea (22), head disease (19), wind pattern (14), Shaoyin disease (12), long time pattern (9), infantile convulsions (9), prostration (8), epilepsy (8), acute pattern (7) Head disease (59), wind pattern (49), jaundice (29), epilepsy (21), acute pattern (19), silence (15), infantile convulsions (13), prostration (12), collapse pattern (12), cold and hot pattern (12), pain pattern (10), syncope (10), cold pattern (8), diarrhea (6), hot pattern (6), convulsions (5) *Omit keywords with frequency less than 5..
6. Specific methods of Baihui moxibustion
Besides direct moxibustion, ancient books also recorded indirect Baihui moxibustion: two mentions each of moxibustion on garlic, moxibustion on ginger, and plaster; and one mention each of moxibustion on locust bark, and lampwick moxibustion.
DISCUSSION
Statistical analyses revealed that Baihui moxibustion was documented across various dynasties. Apart from the Western Han and Eastern Jin Dynasties, where only medical treatises mention Baihui moxibustion, the genre predominantly consists of medical prescriptions in all other dynasties. Since the Yuan Dynasty, the prevalence of medical expounds has gradually increased. Baihui moxibustion involving multiple acupoints has received more attention than single-acupoint moxibustion. During the Northern Song Dynasty, single-acupoint moxibustion was the least frequently mentioned, with only two occurrences. The prevalence of single-acupoint moxibustion gradually increased from the Yuan Dynasty to the Ming Dynasty and further to the Qing Dynasty.
The therapeutic indications of Baihui moxibustion encompass various physiologic systems. The Baihui acupoint serves as the convergence point of Yang qi and the central hub of all meridians [14]. It is efficacious in treating both upper and lower body ailments and can be used for tonification, purgation, invigoration, and constriction. Mugwort, the primary herb used in moxibustion, exhibits properties of divergence, warmth, and bitterness, possessing pure yang attributes. Its application can rescue patients from collapse and facilitate unobstructed flow of the body’s meridians. Internal medicine constitutes the predominant domain within the primary categories of Baihui moxibustion, underscoring the overall leadership role of the Baihui acupoint. Within the secondary categories, the main indications revolve around limb meridian disorders and cerebrovascular ailments, suggesting that Baihui moxibustion can invigorate mental faculties and enhance overall vitality through meridian stimulation. Specific patterns of application predominantly target cranial disorders and wind-related syndromes, indicating the efficacy of Baihui moxibustion in addressing ailments proximal to the Baihui acupoint.
Single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion is effective in treating internal medicine ailments, particularly those affecting the heart and brain, diarrhea, and collapse disorders. Such moxibustion functions by enhancing yang energy and uplifting sinking qi. For example, in the
The
The
Baihui moxibustion encompasses effects such as yang-warming, alleviation of collapse, awakening the mind, and calming agitation, making such moxibustion a versatile treatment for various cognitive disturbances. As stated in
Some doctors have proposed unique insights on the clinical application of Baihui moxibustion.
The primary method of Baihui moxibustion was direct moxibustion, although alternative approaches such as using garlic, ginger, or locust bark were also documented. Historic texts mention combining Baihui moxibustion with external medicine to address conditions like wind-induced head rotation and nasal congestion. For instance,
In researching Baihui acupoint-related practices, Taoist techniques like “storing mud pills” were considered. The
CONCLUSIONS
With the advancement of acupuncture and moxibustion, the clinical use of Baihui moxibustion has evolved across various dynasties, showcasing its versatile methodologies. Indications for Baihui moxibustion are reflected in commanding the whole body and the close treatment effect of local diseases, as well as following the main treatment of meridians and the application of syndrome differentiation and treatment. Single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion potently tonifies and elevates sinking qi, making it effective for conditions characterized by qi deficiency and descent. This research only covered the texts related to Baihui moxibustion in ancient books included in the
FUNDING
This research was funded by the Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 16th Batch of Student Innovation Activity Program Project (No. 202310268131, SHUTCM2023096).
AUTHORS’ CONTRIBUTIONS
Ma YY and Qu CC performed the texts’ search and screen. Ma YY and Chen LM performed the writing. Ji J proposed guidance and modifications. All the authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Fig 1.
Fig 2.
Fig 3.
Fig 4.
Fig 5.
-
Table 1 . Table of synonyms.
Original search term Synonym Baihui Dianshang (巔上, top), Ding Zhongyang (頂中央, top center), Lingshang (嶺上, ridge), Niwan (泥丸, mud pills), Sanyang (三陽, tri-yang) , Wuhui (五會, five convergence), Sanyangwuhui (三陽五會, tri-yang and five convergence), Tianman (天滿), Weihui(維會) Moxibustion Ai (艾, Moxa), Zhuang (壯, stick), Zhi (炙, scorching), Yun (熨, ironing), Lao (烙, branding), Denghuo (燈火, lamp fire)
-
Table 2 . Index example.
Book Text Keyword Shen Ying Jing Sick for a long time and have a runny nose: Baihui moxibustion. ENT, nose disease, internal medicine, lung disease, long pattern, head disease Gu Jin Yi Tong Da Quan: Tuo Gang Hou Baihui, on the top of head, has three sticks of moxibustion to treat pediatric prolapse. Pediatric, surgery, proctology and vulvar disease, collapse pattern Tai Ping Sheng Hui Fang: Ti Huang Zheng Hou Patients who have yellow body, yellow face, sore and stuffy feet and knees, not warm on the body, restless in the heart, slightly aerated in the abdomen, better or worse appetite, prefer covering, but want to sleep in a cold place, should have moxibustion on Baihui, back center and one to two inches, three inches, four inches, and five inches below the heart. Internal medicine, hepatobiliary disease, jaundice, limb meridians. cold and heat pattern, head disease, heart and brain disease, pain pattern
-
Table 3 . The top 10 ancient books in terms of texts.
Ancient book name Dynasty Rank Text Proportion (%) Zheng jiu ji cheng Qing 1 28 8.8 Pu ji fang Ming 2 27 8.4 Sheng ji zong lu Northern Song 3 21 6.6 Zhen jiu zi sheng ji Southern Song 4 17 5.3 Tai ping sheng hui fang Northern Song 5 16 5.0 Gu jin yi tong da quan Ming 6 10 3.1 Bei ji qian ji nyao fang Tang 7 9 2.8 Jiu fa mi chuan Qing 8 8 2.5 Yi xue gang mu Ming 9 7 2.2 Zhen jiu da cheng Ming 10 6 1.9 Qian jin yi fang Tang 10 6 1.9
-
Table 4 . Indications of Baihui Moxibustion.
Category Keyword (frequency) Primary category Internal medicine (263), pediatric (71), surgery (46), ENT (29), gynaecology (11) Secondary category Limb meridians (156), heart and brain (130), hepatology (35), spleen and stomach (32), anorectal and vulva (28), nose disease (11), exogenous disease (9), lung disease (8), trauma (8), eye disease (6), obstetrics (5), dental disease (5), kidney disease (5), skin disease (4), ear disease (3), throat disease (3), leucorrhea disease (2), postpartum disease (2) Specific
patternHead disease (105), wind pattern (76), collapse pattern (46), diarrhea (34), epilepsy (34), jaundice (33), acute pattern (32), infantile convulsions (26), syncope (25), prostration (24), pain pattern (21), cold pattern (19), long time pattern (18), silence (16), cold and hot pattern (15), Shaoyin disease (13), hot pattern (9), convulsions (8), blood pattern (6), phlegm wet pattern (4), sores and carbuncles (2), jueyin disease (1)
-
Table 5 . Indications of single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion and multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion.
Category Single-acupoint Baihui moxibustion (frequency) Multi-acupoint Baihui moxibustion (frequency) Primary category Internal medicine (60), pediatric (24), surgery (19), ENT (4), gynaecology (4) Internal medicine (153), pediatric (37), surgery (19), ENT (19), gynaecology (4) Secondary category Heart and brain (28), limb meridians (23), anorectal and vulva (14), spleen and stomach (14) Limb meridians (96), heart and brain (73), hepatology (31), spleen and stomach (9), exogenous disease (8), anorectal and vulva (8), lung disease (5), nose disease (5) Specific
patternCollapse pattern (22), diarrhea (22), head disease (19), wind pattern (14), Shaoyin disease (12), long time pattern (9), infantile convulsions (9), prostration (8), epilepsy (8), acute pattern (7) Head disease (59), wind pattern (49), jaundice (29), epilepsy (21), acute pattern (19), silence (15), infantile convulsions (13), prostration (12), collapse pattern (12), cold and hot pattern (12), pain pattern (10), syncope (10), cold pattern (8), diarrhea (6), hot pattern (6), convulsions (5) *Omit keywords with frequency less than 5..
References
- Huang F. Zhen Jiu Jia Yi Jing. Xian: Xi'an Jiaotong University Press, 2018, p. 89. Chinese.
- Zhang J. Lei Jing Tu Yi. Beijing: People's Medical Publishing House, 1965, p. 309. Chinese.
- Chen W, Zhang Y, Zhang C, Jia H. [Analysis of ancient clinical application of baihui point based on data mining technology]. Jianxi J Tradit Chin Med 2014;45:27-31. Chinese.
- Yan C. [Overview of Baihui acupoint therapy in ancient books]. J Anhui Uni Chin Med 2013;31:57-60. Chinese.
- Anonymous. Suwen. Taiyuan: Shanxi Science and Technology Press, 2019, p. 121.
- Shanghai Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion Editorial Board. Baihui moxibustion in ancient literatures. Shanghai J Acupunct Moxibustion 2003;11:24.
- Wu Q. Study on Modern Clinical Application of Baihui Moxibustion Therapy. Jinan: Shandong University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2017.
- Qiu P, Deng T, Wang Y. Chinese Medical Classic. 5th ed. Changsha: Human Electronic Audiovisual Press, 2013.
- Shen X. Meridian and Acupoint. 10th ed. Beijing: China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 2016, p. 171.
- Wang D. Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion Acupoint Guide (Part 1). Qingdao: Qingdao Press, 2004, p. 232.
- Gao X. Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion Dictionary. Nanjing: Jiangsu Science and Technology Press, 2010, p. 242.
- Huang L. A study of the origin and development of moxibustion. J Clin Acupunct Moxib 1995;9:11-2.
- Shang W, Zhang H, Duan Q, Hou Y, Jiang D, Meng F. [A study on the practice of online deep citation of ancient Chinese medical books]. J Changchun Uni Chin Med 2013;29:555-7. Chinese.
- Yang J. Compendium of Acupuncture and Moxibustion. Tianjin: Tianjin Science and Technology Press, 2017, p. 86.
- Dou G. Huang Di Ming Tang Jiu Jing Jiu Gao Mang Shu Xue Fa Zi Wu Liu Zhu Zhen Jing Zhen Jing Zhi Nan. Beijing: People's medical publishing, 1983, p. 63.
- Zhu Z, Zhang Q, Deng J, Zhenheng Z, Qiwendeng Z. Dan Xi Zhi Fa Xin Yao. Jinan: Shandong Science Technology Press, 1985, p. 49. Chinese.
- Xu C. Complete Collection of Ancient and Modern Medical Statistics (Part 2). Hefei: Anhui Science and Technology Press, 1995, p. 305.
- Yuan H, Yang B. [Overview of clinical applications of the Baihui acupoint]. J Prac Tradit Chin Med 2021;37:2138-41. Chinese.
- Zhang Z. Treatise on Cold Damage Diseases. Nanning: Guangxi Science and Technology Press, 2015, p. 82.
- Guo Y. Shang Han Bu Wang Lun. Beijing: People's Health Press, 1994, p. 182. Chinese.
- Zhang L. Shang Han Cuan Lun. Beijing: China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 2015, p. 85. Chinese.
- Ke Q. Shang Han Lun Zhu. Beijing: People's Military Medical Electronic Press, 2011, p. 79. Chinese.
- Qian H. Shang Han Su Yuan Ji. Beijing: China Traditional China Medicine Publisher, 2015, p. 335. Chinese.
- Chen M, Zhou J, Feng T, Duan X, Xiao L. [Brief discussion on the clauses without specific acupuncture point in Shanghan Lun]. China J Tradit Chin Med Pharm 2018;33:4031-3. Chinese.
- Gong Y. Shou Shi Bao Yuan. Taiyuan: Shanxi Science and Technology Press, 2006, p. 660. Chinese.
- Li S. Yi Xue Yan Yue. Beijing: China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 1997, p. 233. Chinese.
- Wang Z. Zhen jiu zi sheng jing. Shaghai: Shanghai Scientific and Technical Publishers, 1959, p. 158. Chinese.
- Yang S, Fan D, Su S, Wang C, Lin Y, Liang M. Effects of pressing moxibustion at Baihui (GV 20) and Guanyuan (CV 4) on cognitive impairment and serum levels of Aβ1-42, tau, P-tau in patients with mild to moderate Alzheimer's disease. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 2024;44:255-60.
- Xu CW, Wang TT, Chen LP, Liu XL, Yang Z, Chen DR, et al. Observation on the short-term efficacy of inverse moxibustion at the Baihui point and Dazhui point in preventing post-stroke depression. Explore (NY) 2023;19:607-10.
- Mai W, Bu XZ, Miao FR, Rui JL, Huang LL, Zhao XJ, et al. [Moxibustion at Baihui combined with acupuncture for cervical vertigo: a meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis]. Zhen Ci Yan Jiu 2023;48:95-101. Chinese.
- Ju YL, Chi X, Liu JX. Forty cases of insomnia treated by suspended moxibustion at Baihui (GV 20). J Tradit Chin Med 2009;29:95-6. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0254-6272(09)60040-6.
- Liu K. Song Feng Shuo Yi. Beijing: People's Health Press, 1987, p. 107. Chinese.
- Zhao J. Sheng Ji Zong Lu. Beijing: China Traditional Chinese Medicine Press, 2018, p. 2524. Chinese.
- Zhu Z. Puji Fang Book 2 Body Shape. Beijing: People's Health Press, 1959, p. 78.
- Danbo K. Yi Xin Fang. Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press, 1998, p. 1124. Chinese.
- Wang LF, Meng YL. [Study on literatures of health preservation and practitioners in
Taiping Yulan :Fangshu ]. Zhonghua Yi Shi Za Zhi 2019;49:224-8. Chinese. - Jing X. A study on the origin of the brain marrow theory in traditional Chinese medicine. China J Tradit Chin Med Pharm 1997;5:21-24+64.